1. Home
  2. Entertainment
  3. Country Music

Various Artists - This is Americana

About.com Rating four out of Five

From Kathy Coleman, for About.com

This is Americana - Various Artists

This is Americana - Various Artists

The Bottom Line

Weirdly eccentric, heavy on the country side of Americana, with legends such as Willie Nelson, Johnny Cash, and Ray Price; but includes such underground songwriters as Jim Lauderdale and Lucinda Williams. Americana's identity from this point of view isn't uncertain, as they say, this IS Americana.
Pros
  • "September When It Comes"
  • "Life In The Country"
  • "Gold Watch & Chain"
Cons
  • None.

Description

  • Collection of 21 songs chosen by the Americana Music Association.
  • Includes extensive liner notes and lists of "essential" Americana albums.
  • Represents "a significant, yet only a small" sampling of the genre.

Guide Review - Various Artists - This is Americana

I recently saw a rant in an Americana newsletter complaining that "Americana" was becoming too commercial and it was time for country roots music to break out on its own. I suppose I can understand this; every time the mainstream gets a'hold of something that's becoming popular, it's inevitably spoiled by suits who want to wring more money out of it. It's also understandable when listening to this sampler of Americana music. While I have my own definition of what "Americana" is, it seems it's impossible to pin down.

Country? Seems it must be, with names like Cash, Nelson, Price, BR549, Lauderdale, and Junior Brown. But wait. Bluegrass? There're Ralph Stanley and Alison Krauss. Or straight-up roots, with Slaid Cleaves, Fairfax, the Jayhawks, and the gravel-voiced Arthur Godfrey? Mostly, "This Is Americana" leans to the country side, leaning heavily on the mountain and honky-tonk sound with some twists and turns provided by a rich and varied tapestry of artists.

No matter how you define the genre, the simple truth is, it's good. It's worth hearing. I'd love for it to be more popular, but refer to my first paragraph for the deep pitfalls that can lead to. Those that seek it out will find it, and hopefully enjoy it. Especially wondrous and moving is Johnny and Rosanne Cash singing "September When it Comes," her voice of liquid gold overshadowed by her father's tremulous, venerable vocals, only which gained in poignance as he entered the last years of his life.

Compare Prices

Explore Country Music

More from About.com

  1. Home
  2. Entertainment
  3. Country Music
  4. Reviews
  5. CD Reviews - M-Z
  6. Various Artists - This is Americana

©2008 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.