1. Home
  2. Entertainment
  3. Country Music

Neil Young - Living With War

About.com Rating five out of Five

From Kathy Coleman, for About.com

Neil Young - Living With War

Neil Young - Living With War

Special Ops Media

The Bottom Line

There's no way everyone is going to like this album. It will, I believe, appeal to exactly one side of the entire Red State/Blue State debate, although its timeliness can't be argued. Nor can the brilliance of Neil Young's playing, singing, and songwriting. Still, one can't look at this disc in any way objectively considering the subject matter. It's a terse, to-the-point look at the political climate today, and really, there's no one better to do it than Young.
Pros
  • "Let's Impeach the President"
  • "Looking for a Leader"
  • "Shock & Awe"
  • "Families"
Cons
  • None

Description

  • Ten tracks, nine originals with a cover of "America The Beautiful."
  • Produced and arranged by Neil Young, co-produced with Niko Bolas and L.A. Johnson.
  • A straight-ahead, no-holds-barred protest album from one of the greatest singer/songwriters alive.

Guide Review - Neil Young - Living With War

When the man who wrote the earth-shaking protest anthem "Ohio" ("Tin soldiers and Nixon coming/ We're finally on our own/ This summer I hear the drumming/ Four dead in Ohio") takes a stand against the current political climate, it's impossible not to listen. I'm sure there will be those who will refuse to hear, but they should still listen.

There are no punches pulled here. Young speaks out frankly and truthfully, ripping news from the headlines and putting it in his razor-edged lyrics. From the hard one-two punch of "Shock & Awe" ("Back in the days of 'mission accomplished'/ Our chief was landing on the deck/ The sun was setting on a golden photo op/ Back in the days of 'mission accomplished'/ Thousands of bodies in the ground/ Brought home in a boxes to a trumpet's sound/ No one sees them coming home that way") to the TKO of "Let's Impeach The President," which includes some of Bush's more contradictory phrases (in Bush's own voice, no less), Neil Young is not at all afraid to tell it as he sees it.

Young's voice is still as craggy as it ever was, his delivery just as crisp. He remains a modern classic, an artist of incredible depth and honesty. His powerful roots sound makes this album a terrific straightforward folk-rock album whether or not one agrees with the politics. The disc closes with a painfully honest, absolutely straightforward choral version of "America the Beautiful," reminding us all what this country is, and should be. Thank you, Neil Young.

Compare Prices

Explore Country Music

More from About.com

  1. Home
  2. Entertainment
  3. Country Music
  4. Reviews
  5. CD Reviews - M-Z
  6. Neil Young - Living With War

©2008 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.