- Overall Look 5.0
- Quality of Performance 4.5
- Emotion 4.5
- Song Choice 5.0
- Originality 4.5
- Personality 5.0
- Stage Presence 4.0
- Confidence 5.0
- It Factor 4.5
- Risk Taker 4.5
Total Points: 46.5
My Total Rankings for the Finalists in Episode 1
- Monique LeCompte - 46.5
- Chris Young - 46.5
- Kristin McNamara - 46.0
- Casey Rivers - 45.5
- Matt Mason - 44.5
- Jared Ashley - 44.5
- Melanie Torres - 43.5
- Shy Blakeman - 42.5
- Nicole Jamrose - 39.0